Shopping guide

Macy's vs Nordstrom: Which Department Store Offers Better Value?

By SampleSalesNYC Editorial Team ·

Woman comparing two dresses on hangers inside a bright department store

Short answer: Macy's usually offers better value on everyday basics, home goods and gifts, because its prices start lower and its sales and rewards stack often. Nordstrom offers better value on mid-range and designer fashion you plan to keep for years, because its service, free alterations perks, price matching and flexible returns lower the real cost of getting it right.

Both stores sell many of the same brands, so the price tag alone rarely settles the question. What matters is what you buy, how often you shop, and how much you care about fit help, returns and loyalty perks. This guide compares the two side by side, then shows how New York shoppers can get many of the same labels for even less at NYC sample sales this week.

If you are still deciding which department stores belong on your list at all, start with our roundup of the 15 best department stores in the USA, then come back here for the head-to-head.

Quick picks: which store wins for what

  • Lowest everyday prices: Macy's
  • Home, kitchen and bedding: Macy's
  • Holiday gifts on a budget: Macy's
  • Designer and contemporary fashion: Nordstrom
  • Shoes and fit help: Nordstrom
  • Returns with the least stress: Nordstrom
  • Price protection after you buy: Nordstrom (it also matches listed competitors)
  • Off-price bargains: Nordstrom Rack, with Macy's Backstage close behind

Macy's vs Nordstrom at a glance

FactorMacy'sNordstrom
Typical price tier$–$$$$–$$$$
OwnershipMacy's, Inc. (also owns Bloomingdale's and Bluemercury)Private since 2025: the Nordstrom family and Mexican retailer El Puerto de Liverpool
Store footprintLarge national chain, shrinking to roughly 350 core storesFewer than 100 full-line stores plus a larger Nordstrom Rack network
NYC flagshipHerald Square, 34th Street225 W. 57th Street, with a men's store across Broadway
Standard return window30 days for most items, extended for holiday purchasesNo fixed time limit; handled case by case
Price adjustmentsMacy's own price drops within 10 daysIts own and listed competitors' price drops within 10 days
Loyalty programStar Rewards (Bronze to Platinum)The Nordy Club (Member to Icon)
Off-price bannerMacy's Backstage (mostly inside Macy's stores)Nordstrom Rack (stand-alone stores and online)
Best forBasics, home, beauty gift sets, kids, big sale eventsDesigner, contemporary, shoes, service, alterations
Macy's vs Nordstrom value scorecard An editorial scorecard rating each store from 1 to 5 on six value factors. Macy's scores higher on everyday prices, home goods and sale frequency. Nordstrom scores higher on returns, service and price protection. Value scorecard (editorial rating, 1–5) Macy's Nordstrom Everyday prices Home and gifts Sale frequency Returns Service and fit help Price protection 53 53 54 35 35 35

Prices and brand mix

Macy's is a mid-market store. A large share of its floor space goes to its own labels and to accessible national brands, so a sweater, a pair of sheets or a work blouse often starts well under what you would pay at Nordstrom. It also runs frequent storewide events and coupons, which means the "regular" price is rarely the price most people pay.

Nordstrom sits a step higher. Its floors lean toward contemporary and designer labels, premium denim, and a deep shoe department. You will find affordable house brands there too, but the average item costs more. The trade-off is that Nordstrom marks down less often outside its big events, so the price you see is closer to the price you pay.

Where the two overlap

Many contemporary labels show up at both stores or at their sister banners, so comparison shopping is worth the two minutes. Check the same item, size and color on both sites before you buy. If Macy's is cheaper on an identical item, Nordstrom lists Macy's among the competitors it will price match, which can save you a trip.

Sales and events

Macy's: frequent, stackable promotions

Macy's runs some kind of sale most weeks: one-day sales, friends-and-family events, holiday doorbusters and clearance. Star Rewards members also get periodic offers, and Star Money can be applied on top of many promotions. If you are patient and watch the calendar, you rarely need to pay full price at Macy's.

Nordstrom: fewer, bigger moments

Nordstrom concentrates its savings into a handful of events. The best known is the Anniversary Sale each summer, which is unusual because it discounts new fall merchandise before it goes to full price. Higher Nordy Club tiers get early access to shop it. Nordstrom also runs half-yearly sales and holiday promotions, but between them, discounts are thinner than at Macy's.

Returns: the biggest difference in day-to-day value

A good return policy is a hidden discount. It lowers the cost of a wrong size or a gift that misses.

  • Macy's: most items can be returned within 30 days of purchase or delivery, and holiday purchases usually get a longer window into January. Some categories have shorter windows or are final sale, including Last Act clearance. In-store returns are free; mail returns are free for Star Rewards members, while non-members pay a flat fee taken from the refund.
  • Nordstrom: there is no fixed time limit on returns. Each one is handled case by case, and receipts are not always required. Designer items and special-occasion dresses need tags attached, and Nordstrom Rack has its own, shorter windows.

For anything you might need to exchange, such as shoes, jeans or a coat, Nordstrom's policy is worth real money. Our jeans fit guide and walking shoes guide explain why fit-sensitive items are the ones most often sent back.

Price adjustments and price matching

Both stores refund the difference if a price drops shortly after you buy, but the rules differ in an important way.

  • Macy's adjusts for its own lower advertised price within 10 days of purchase, with a longer holiday price guarantee in late fall. It does not match other retailers, and clearance and some promotions are excluded.
  • Nordstrom adjusts within 10 days of purchase or shipment, and it also matches a published list of competitors that includes Macy's, Bloomingdale's, Saks Fifth Avenue and Amazon. The item must be identical and in stock at both. Anniversary Sale prices, flash deals and sale-priced designer items are excluded.

In practice, Nordstrom's version protects you better when you buy a full-price item from a brand that is sold widely.

Loyalty programs compared

Macy's Star Rewards

Anyone can join for free at the Bronze level and earn 1 point per dollar. Opening a Macy's credit card starts you at Silver with a higher earn rate, and cardholders who spend more each year move up to Gold and Platinum, where the effective rebate reaches about 5%. Every 1,000 points becomes $10 in Star Money, which expires 30 days after it is issued. Members also get free mail returns, and higher tiers get easier free shipping.

The Nordy Club

Nordstrom's program also starts free. Members earn points on purchases, and 2,000 points becomes a $20 Nordstrom Note, so the base return is about 1%. The tiers (Member, Influencer, Ambassador and Icon) are set by annual spend, and the Nordstrom credit card raises the earn rate. The more useful perks are not points: alteration credits at higher tiers, early access to the Anniversary Sale, and Double Points Days.

Which program pays more?

For a light shopper without a store card, the two are close, around 1% back. Macy's pays more often because its promotions are so frequent. Nordstrom pays better for shoppers who buy tailored pieces, because alteration credits can be worth more than the points themselves.

Service, fit help and the in-store experience

Nordstrom built its reputation on service, and it still shows. Stylists are free, salespeople in shoes and denim tend to know their stock, and many stores offer on-site alterations. The New York flagship at 57th Street and Broadway, which opened in 2019, has seven levels, a large denim bar, a cobbler and express returns, with a separate men's store across the street.

Macy's is more self-service. Floors are big and busy, and staffing can be thin during peak hours. The Herald Square flagship on 34th Street is one of the largest department stores in the world and a destination in its own right, especially in December. It is good for one-stop errands: kitchenware, bedding, cosmetics and a coat in one trip.

Off-price: Nordstrom Rack vs Macy's Backstage

Both companies run off-price formats for shoppers who want brand names for less.

  • Nordstrom Rack: stand-alone stores
  • Rack: shorter return windows
  • Backstage: inside many Macy's stores
  • Backstage: home and kids deals

Nordstrom Rack is the stronger of the two for fashion. It has its own stores and website, gets a mix of Nordstrom leftovers and goods bought for Rack, and is expanding. Its return rules are much tighter than full-line Nordstrom, so check the window before you buy. Macy's Backstage mostly lives inside regular Macy's stores, and it is at its best for home goods, kids' clothes and toys.

Is the company behind each store stable?

This matters for gift cards, store credit and loyalty balances. Nordstrom became a private company in May 2025, when the Nordstrom family and El Puerto de Liverpool completed their buyout, and brothers Erik and Pete Nordstrom continue to run it. Macy's is in the middle of its "Bold New Chapter" plan, which includes closing about 150 weaker stores by the end of 2026 while investing in roughly 350 core locations, Bloomingdale's and Bluemercury. Neither change affects how you shop today, but if your local Macy's is on a closing list, spend Star Money and store credit early.

How to choose between Macy's and Nordstrom

  1. Buying basics, home or gifts? Start at Macy's and wait for a sale event.
  2. Buying something you will wear for years? Start at Nordstrom for fit help and returns.
  3. Not sure about size? Buy where returns are easiest, which is usually Nordstrom.
  4. Found the same item at both? Ask Nordstrom to price match the lower one.
  5. Shopping off-price? Try Nordstrom Rack for clothes and shoes, Macy's Backstage for home.
  6. Carrying a store card? Shop mostly where your rewards tier is highest.

How to buy department store brands for less at NYC sample sales

Here is the part most comparisons leave out. Many of the contemporary and designer labels on Macy's and Nordstrom floors hold their own sample sales in New York, often at 50% to 80% off retail. Labels such as Theory, Vince, Rag & Bone, Veronica Beard, Tory Burch, Kate Spade, Michael Kors and Eileen Fisher all show up on the New York sample sale calendar.

The catch is that sample sales trade the department store's comfort for price. Sales are usually final, sizes run out fast, and fitting rooms may be a curtained corner or nothing at all. That makes them ideal for pieces you already know fit you, perhaps a style you tried on at Nordstrom or Macy's, and less ideal for something new. Our guide to how sample sales work covers the basics, and the discounts by brand type page shows what to expect from each kind of label.

Sample sale tips for department store shoppers

  1. Try it on at the department store first. Note your size in each brand so you can buy confidently at a final-sale event.
  2. Check the calendar weekly. The NYC sample sales calendar lists dates, venues and hours as they are announced.
  3. Go early on day one, or late on the last day. Day one has the best selection; the final day often brings deeper markdowns.
  4. Know the department store price. Look the item up on your phone before you pay so you know the real saving.
  5. Wear fitted layers. Leggings and a tank top let you try things on in the aisle when there are no fitting rooms.
  6. Bring a tote and expect card-only checkout at some sales. Read our first-timer's guide for what else to pack.
  7. Plan holiday shopping around both. Our Black Friday sample sales guide and Thanksgiving and Black Friday store hours help you map a route that hits both.

For category-specific picks, see our guides to the best women's clothing brands in the USA, the best handbag brands for women and the best winter coats for women, all of which point to brands that also appear at sample sales.

The verdict

Macy's is the better value when the goal is the lowest price on everyday items, home goods and gifts, especially if you shop its frequent sales and use Star Rewards. Nordstrom is the better value when the goal is getting a quality piece right the first time, because its returns, price matching and service reduce the hidden costs of buying clothes and shoes.

Most New Yorkers end up using both: Macy's for the practical list, Nordstrom for the investment pieces. Add sample sales to the mix for the brands you already know and love, and you can pay well below either store's price. Browse every brand with an NYC sample sale to see which of your favorites are coming up next.

Frequently asked questions

Is Macy's or Nordstrom cheaper?

Macy's is usually cheaper. Its prices start lower, it carries more accessible brands and private labels, and it runs sales and coupons most weeks. Nordstrom costs more on average but discounts less often outside big events like the Anniversary Sale.

Which has the better return policy, Macy's or Nordstrom?

Nordstrom. It has no fixed time limit on returns and handles each one case by case. Macy's accepts most returns within 30 days, with a longer window for holiday purchases, and some items such as Last Act clearance are final sale.

Does Nordstrom price match Macy's?

Yes. Nordstrom includes Macy's on its list of competitors it will price match within 10 days of purchase or shipment, as long as the item is identical and in stock at both. Anniversary Sale, flash sale and sale-priced designer items are excluded.

Does Macy's price match other stores?

No. Macy's only adjusts the price if Macy's itself lowers its advertised price within 10 days of your purchase, with a longer holiday price guarantee in late fall. It does not match other retailers.

Is the Nordy Club or Macy's Star Rewards better?

For shoppers without a store card, both return about 1%. Star Rewards pays out more often because Macy's runs frequent promotions. The Nordy Club is better for shoppers who buy tailored pieces, because higher tiers include alteration credits and early Anniversary Sale access.

Is Nordstrom Rack better than Macy's Backstage?

For clothing and shoes, Nordstrom Rack is usually better: it has stand-alone stores, a large website and a wide brand mix. Macy's Backstage, which mostly sits inside Macy's stores, is strongest for home goods, kids' clothes and toys.

Can I buy Nordstrom and Macy's brands for less in NYC?

Yes. Many contemporary labels sold at both stores, including Theory, Vince, Rag & Bone, Tory Burch and Kate Spade, hold sample sales in New York, often at 50% to 80% off retail. Sales are usually final, so buy sizes you already know.

Get new NYC sample sales first: follow SampleSalesNYC on WhatsApp

Follow on WhatsApp

Never miss a sample sale again

One email every Monday morning with the week’s sales, plus a heads-up when a brand you follow announces one.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

More shopping guides